Does an Old Fashioned Have a Cherry? Tradition vs. Personal Preference

The Old Fashioned is a classic cocktail that has stood the test of time, remaining a popular choice among whiskey enthusiasts and cocktail aficionados. Its simple yet sophisticated composition makes it a timeless beverage, enjoyed for its balanced flavors and versatility. The traditional ingredients of an Old Fashioned include whiskey, sugar, bitters, and water, with variations incorporating additional elements like orange peel and cherries.

What is an Old Fashioned?

The Old Fashioned’s origins date back to the 19th century, with its exact birthplace and creator shrouded in mystery. Some believe it originated in Louisville, Kentucky, while others attribute its creation to New York City. Regardless of its exact origins, the Old Fashioned quickly gained popularity and became a staple in bars and social gatherings. The traditional recipe calls for a combination of whiskey, sugar, bitters, and water, stirred together and served over ice in an old-fashioned glass.

Ingredient Breakdown

• Whiskey: The heart of an Old Fashioned lies in the choice of whiskey. Traditionally, bourbon or rye whiskey is used, each imparting its unique character to the cocktail. Bourbon, known for its sweet and smoky notes, adds a rich complexity to the drink, while rye whiskey’s spicy and assertive flavor profile creates a bolder Old Fashioned.
• Sugar: Sugar plays a crucial role in balancing the flavors of the cocktail. Traditionally, a sugar cube is used and muddled with a few drops of water to create a simple syrup. This method allows the sugar to dissolve quickly and evenly, ensuring a smooth and consistent texture.
• Bitters: Bitters, an aromatic liquid made from various herbs, spices, and roots, add a layer of complexity and depth to the Old Fashioned. Angostura bitters are commonly used, contributing their signature bittersweet flavor and enhancing the whiskey’s characteristics.
• Water: A small amount of water is added to help dissolve the sugar and dilute the whiskey, creating a more balanced and approachable drink.

Garnishes and Variations

• Orange Peel: The classic garnish for an Old Fashioned is an orange peel, expressed over the drink to release its citrusy oils. This adds a refreshing and aromatic element to the cocktail, complementing the whiskey’s flavors.
• Cherries: While not a traditional garnish, cherries are sometimes used in variations of the Old Fashioned. Luxardo cherries, known for their rich flavor and plump texture, are a popular choice. However, the use of cherries in an Old Fashioned is a matter of personal preference and is not considered a standard ingredient.

Controversy Surrounding Cherries

The inclusion of cherries in an Old Fashioned has been a subject of debate among cocktail enthusiasts. Traditionalists argue that a cherry is not part of the original recipe and dilutes the integrity of the classic cocktail. They maintain that the orange peel provides sufficient garnish and aromatic enhancement. On the other hand, some bartenders and drinkers appreciate the addition of a cherry, believing it adds a touch of sweetness and visual appeal to the drink.

Popular Serving Styles

Different bars and bartenders may have their own interpretations of the Old Fashioned, leading to variations in serving styles. Some prefer to serve the cocktail in a rocks glass, while others opt for an old-fashioned glass. The size of the ice cubes used can also vary, with larger cubes melting slower and diluting the drink less. Additionally, some variations may include additional ingredients like a splash of soda water or a twist of lemon peel.

Conclusion

The Old Fashioned remains a timeless classic, appreciated for its simplicity and versatility. While the traditional recipe forms the foundation of this iconic cocktail, variations and personal preferences have influenced its evolution over time. The question of whether an Old Fashioned should include a cherry is ultimately a matter of taste and preference. Whether one prefers the traditional garnish of an orange peel or enjoys the addition of a cherry, the Old Fashioned continues to captivate cocktail enthusiasts with its enduring charm and sophisticated flavors.

Additional Tips and Recommendations

• For a classic Old Fashioned, use high-quality whiskey and fresh ingredients.
• If you don’t have sugar cubes, you can use granulated sugar or simple syrup.
• Use a muddler to gently crush the sugar cube and orange peel, releasing their flavors.
• Stir the cocktail for at least 30 seconds to properly incorporate the ingredients and chill the drink.
• Serve the Old Fashioned over a large ice cube or sphere to prevent rapid dilution.
• For those who prefer a sweeter Old Fashioned, add an extra sugar cube or a teaspoon of simple syrup.
• If you dislike cherries, you can garnish your Old Fashioned with an orange twist or a lemon peel instead.

References and Sources

• Classic Old Fashioned Recipe: https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/162397/classic-old-fashioned/
• The Dos and Don’ts of Making an Old Fashioned: https://www.liquor.com/articles/the-dos-and-donts-of-making-an-old-fashioned/
• The Perfect Old Fashioned Cocktail: https://www.thekitchenmagpie.com/the-perfect-old-fashioned-cocktail/

FAQs

Does an Old Fashioned traditionally have a cherry?

No, a traditional Old Fashioned does not include a cherry as a standard garnish. The classic recipe consists of whiskey, sugar, bitters, and water, with an orange peel as the traditional garnish.

Why is there debate about cherries in an Old Fashioned?

The inclusion of cherries in an Old Fashioned is a matter of personal preference and is not considered a standard ingredient. Some purists argue that a cherry dilutes the integrity of the classic cocktail, while others appreciate the touch of sweetness and visual appeal it adds.

What is the traditional garnish for an Old Fashioned?

The traditional garnish for an Old Fashioned is an orange peel, expressed over the drink to release its citrusy oils. The orange peel complements the whiskey’s flavors and adds a refreshing aromatic element.

Can I use a cherry in my Old Fashioned if I like?

Yes, you can certainly add a cherry to your Old Fashioned if you enjoy the flavor combination. However, it’s important to note that a cherry is not a traditional ingredient and its inclusion is a matter of personal preference.

What are some variations of the Old Fashioned that include cherries?

Some variations of the Old Fashioned may include a cherry as a garnish or even as an ingredient. For example, the “Wisconsin Old Fashioned” typically includes a maraschino cherry and a splash of sour mix.

Are there any other alternatives to cherries for garnishing an Old Fashioned?

Yes, there are several alternatives to cherries for garnishing an Old Fashioned. Some popular options include an orange twist, a lemon peel, or a cinnamon stick. You can choose the garnish that best suits your taste preferences.